We never fell out of love. It's the story of our lives. Keith Yeah, I'm screwed up. I'll admit it. People think they know why. After all, my superstar brother's past looms large. Don't I wish it were that simple? It would be so easy to blame all my problems on the childhood tragedy that ripped my family in two...but it would also be a lie. Sam knows the truth. She's always known and yet, she's loved me from the start. I try so hard to hold onto her but I'm messed up. And she's not going to wait forever. Samantha No one saw us coming. I was the quiet, smart girl on track to college. He was the aimless high school surfer/stoner on track to expulsion. We helped each other. We fell in love. We were supposed to live happily ever after. But with Keith McKallister love has never been enough.