Courts Without Cases: The Law and Politics of Advisory Opinions
Autor Dr Carissima Mathenen Limba Engleză Hardback – 18 apr 2019
When one thinks of courts, it is most often in the context of deciding cases: live disputes involving spirited, adversarial debate between opposing parties. Sometimes, though, a court is granted the power to answer questions in the absence of such disputes through advisory opinions (also called references). These proceedings raise many questions: about the judicial role, about the relationship between courts and those who seek their 'advice', and about the nature of law.
Tracking their use in Canada since the country's Confederation and looking to the experience of other legal systems, the book considers how advisory opinions draw courts into the complex relationship between law and politics.
With attention to key themes such as the separation of powers, federalism, rights and precedent, this book provides an important and timely study of a fascinating phenomenon.
| Toate formatele și edițiile | Preț | Express |
|---|---|---|
| Paperback (1) | 278.43 lei 6-8 săpt. | |
| Bloomsbury Publishing – 19 noi 2020 | 278.43 lei 6-8 săpt. | |
| Hardback (1) | 554.98 lei 3-5 săpt. | |
| Bloomsbury Publishing – 18 apr 2019 | 554.98 lei 3-5 săpt. |
Preț: 554.98 lei
Preț vechi: 837.31 lei
-34%
Puncte Express: 832
Preț estimativ în valută:
98.24€ • 114.61$ • 85.06£
98.24€ • 114.61$ • 85.06£
Carte disponibilă
Livrare economică 05-19 februarie
Preluare comenzi: 021 569.72.76
Specificații
ISBN-13: 9781509922499
ISBN-10: 1509922490
Pagini: 280
Dimensiuni: 156 x 234 x 23 mm
Greutate: 0.57 kg
Editura: Bloomsbury Publishing
Colecția Hart Publishing
Locul publicării:London, United Kingdom
ISBN-10: 1509922490
Pagini: 280
Dimensiuni: 156 x 234 x 23 mm
Greutate: 0.57 kg
Editura: Bloomsbury Publishing
Colecția Hart Publishing
Locul publicării:London, United Kingdom
Cuprins
Introduction
1. Courts with Cases
What Do Courts Do?
The Power, and Limits, of Cases
The Separation of Powers
Separation of Powers in Canada
2. Apex Courts
The Judicial Committee
'A Judicial Department in Every Well-Organized Government'
A. Confederation
B. Establishment
3. Canadian References
Framing the Function
Early Quiet, Early Reform
Squaring Advisory Opinions with a General Court of Appeal
Putting the 'Advisory' in an Advisory Function
4. Separate Functions - Separate Powers
Executive Requests and Judicial Resistance
The Lonely Legislature?
5. Arbitrating Federalism
Federalism Post-Confederation
A. Treaties
B. Disallowance
C. Marriage
Apex Change - The Revamped Court
A. Natural Resources
B. Infl ation and Emergency
C. Inter-provincial Trade
Current Battles
A. Criminal Law
B. Economic Regulation
C. Environment and Development
6. Rebirth, and Rupture
Supreme at Last
Constitutional Rebirth
A. The Path to Change
B. Patriation
C. Consequences: Quebec Veto
7. Interpretation and Rights
Prologue: Process and Persons
An Age of Rights
A. Fundamental Justice and Criminal Fault (Motor Vehicle)
B. The Rule of Law (Manitoba Language)
C. Competing Constitutional Interests (Bill 30)
D. Revisiting Past Decisions (Prostitution)
E. The Intersection of Individual Rights, Federalism and Politics (Same-Sex Marriage)
8. Institutions
Rupture, for Real: Quebec Secession
Amendment, Actors and Judicial Supremacy
A. Frozen in Time: Senate Reform
B. Self-entrenchment
9. Actors, Advice and Law
The Core Tension
Why Pursue?
A. Doctrinal Guidance
B. Co-ordination
C. Strategy
D. Imprimatur
Why Not Comply?
Why Comply?
10. The Advisory Court
Process
Authority, Precedent, Stare Decisis
Providing Answers
A. Abstract Review
B. Answers, Declarations, Remedies
Conclusion
1. Courts with Cases
What Do Courts Do?
The Power, and Limits, of Cases
The Separation of Powers
Separation of Powers in Canada
2. Apex Courts
The Judicial Committee
'A Judicial Department in Every Well-Organized Government'
A. Confederation
B. Establishment
3. Canadian References
Framing the Function
Early Quiet, Early Reform
Squaring Advisory Opinions with a General Court of Appeal
Putting the 'Advisory' in an Advisory Function
4. Separate Functions - Separate Powers
Executive Requests and Judicial Resistance
The Lonely Legislature?
5. Arbitrating Federalism
Federalism Post-Confederation
A. Treaties
B. Disallowance
C. Marriage
Apex Change - The Revamped Court
A. Natural Resources
B. Infl ation and Emergency
C. Inter-provincial Trade
Current Battles
A. Criminal Law
B. Economic Regulation
C. Environment and Development
6. Rebirth, and Rupture
Supreme at Last
Constitutional Rebirth
A. The Path to Change
B. Patriation
C. Consequences: Quebec Veto
7. Interpretation and Rights
Prologue: Process and Persons
An Age of Rights
A. Fundamental Justice and Criminal Fault (Motor Vehicle)
B. The Rule of Law (Manitoba Language)
C. Competing Constitutional Interests (Bill 30)
D. Revisiting Past Decisions (Prostitution)
E. The Intersection of Individual Rights, Federalism and Politics (Same-Sex Marriage)
8. Institutions
Rupture, for Real: Quebec Secession
Amendment, Actors and Judicial Supremacy
A. Frozen in Time: Senate Reform
B. Self-entrenchment
9. Actors, Advice and Law
The Core Tension
Why Pursue?
A. Doctrinal Guidance
B. Co-ordination
C. Strategy
D. Imprimatur
Why Not Comply?
Why Comply?
10. The Advisory Court
Process
Authority, Precedent, Stare Decisis
Providing Answers
A. Abstract Review
B. Answers, Declarations, Remedies
Conclusion
Recenzii
This book is the first in-depth study of the profound impact on Canadian constitutional law produced by judicial "advisory opinions" issued in response to the direct "reference" of legal questions to the courts by governments. From the Persons case to the Secession Reference, reference opinions have come to dominate the Canadian constitutional landscape. But the reference procedure has been oddly overlooked by constitutional scholars-until now. For Carissima Mathen, this unusual point of legal procedure is the vehicle for a magisterial exploration of the history, politics, theory, and practice of constitutionalism in Canada. Courts Without Cases is a brilliant contribution to the literature on Canadian constitutional law and politics.
Courts Without Cases is a lucid, original, insightful and highly readable contribution to our understanding of law and politics. References brought by Government to the Supreme Court have led to many of the most important Supreme Court decisions, from same-sex marriage to Quebec's secession, from the regulation of prostitution, guns and financial markets to the composition of the Senate and the Supreme Court itself. Mathen masterfully weaves the story of these significant judgments with the political and institutional dynamics which shape them.
All in all, this book is a very welcome contribution to our understanding of the roles and workings of courts and of the dynamics between law and politics, especially in common law settings.
Courts Without Cases is a lucid, original, insightful and highly readable contribution to our understanding of law and politics. References brought by Government to the Supreme Court have led to many of the most important Supreme Court decisions, from same-sex marriage to Quebec's secession, from the regulation of prostitution, guns and financial markets to the composition of the Senate and the Supreme Court itself. Mathen masterfully weaves the story of these significant judgments with the political and institutional dynamics which shape them.
All in all, this book is a very welcome contribution to our understanding of the roles and workings of courts and of the dynamics between law and politics, especially in common law settings.