"Jordan, I've come to a conclusion-I am never going to be able to be faithful to one woman. I've tried, and it's just not something I am capable of. I will never be able to just be with one woman; however, I truly believe that I could be faithful to two." With these words, Jordan Peck has her life turned upside down. Chase DeWitt, former college crush and current close friend, has always been candid about the infidelities he has committed throughout his marriage to Kendra. "When It's Broke, It's Perfect" looks at the relationships between men and women: platonic, physical, and romantic. What happens when "The One That Got Away" makes you can offer too good to turn down?