Dating is hard and complicated enough, but even more so when you find out that your new love interest and old love are good friends. Jaci Christian, a 29-year-old woman living in Kansas City, Missouri, has been dumped and done her fair share of dating. After her most recent break up, she decides to put a pause on her dating life. This is short-lived because she ends up meeting two very handsome men in one day and thinks that maybe she shouldn't swear off dating after all. When one of them, Jackson, takes things a step further and asks her out on a date, she's very eager to say yes. As she explores a potential relationship with him, a bomb is dropped in their "get to know you" stage in the form of Jackson being good friends with her ex-love that she thought she'd spend the rest of her life with. Being dumped yet again, but this time because of the bro code, Jaci moves on with someone she meets while out with friends. Well, Jaci thought she had moved on until Jackson comes back to her with a proposal she might not be able to refuse. As she navigates dating and friendships, she must decide if her chances are better going back to a past relationship or moving forward with someone new.