Hailey Peters has always held onto the familiar. From the way she wears her hair, to dating her childhood friend-turned high school sweetheart--she sticks with what she knows, and she's convinced herself that this is what makes her happy. Chase Lancaster doesn't play by the rules. He's a classically trained pianist who rocks out in a punk rock band every weekend, and isn't afraid of taking chances. When they are assigned to co-write a song for their college music class, Hailey can't imagine anyone she has anything less in common with than Chase. She is a sweater-wearing, neat freak, and he is disheveled and rough around the edges. As they spend time together, they both find a place in each other's lives-a place where they challenge each other to be different and to embrace the unfamiliar. Hailey never planned for a Chase Lancaster in her life, and she is about to find out that this walking contradiction will change her forever.