Jeremiah Yoder made a bad decision in his youth and left the Mennonite church. He's back now, but what will it take to convince the people of Pinecraft that he's changed. Shelley Burkholder doesn't know what to think about Jeremiah anymore. Even as children, there was a spark between them, yet he made her nervous, too. Now that he's back, it seems the spark has doubled...along with the discomfort. Will Shelley and Jeremiah let God smooth the rough patches to bring them together?