After being best friends for a few years, Nate finally decides to tell Lily that he's in love with her. Only his timing isn't that great since Lily just announced she's engaged to Brice. Lily doesn't know how to handle this news since it would make her delve into feelings unknown and Nate's trying his best to give her space to sort things out. They try to keep it all a secret from their best friend, Mason, and especially Brice. But soon secrets will be spilled and Lily must face an important decision; choose between the only love she has known and the one that could be.