Following the advice of her trusty horoscope, Caterina Clemmons has decided it's time to do what she's always dreamed of doing, opening her own craft shop and becoming her own boss. Things slowly fall into place, and she relocates to New Hampshire where she meets Quentin, a fellow shopkeeper, who is both charming and hot. Alas, as her horoscope makes no mention of dating a mysterious stranger, she refuses when he asks her to dinner, telling him they are destined to be friends and only friends. Quentin Hunter has been turned down by girls plenty of times before, but never because of a horoscope prediction, and he's determined not to give up on the beautiful Cat because he knows she is worth the challenge he's facing.