Welcome to Kosher Harbor, a town where not everything is as kosher as it may seem. A year has passed since the destruction of Hurricane Candi. Since then, the citizens of the small-town struggle to move on, wearing fake smiles and building new and sometimes strange friendships. What once was a quiet coastal town is slowly turning into a place with many secrets and horrifying deaths. When Kosher Harbor's oldest family, the Hamiltons, volunteer to help host the annual fish-fry, they end up serving up more than their neighbors can chew. At the center of the chaos are Winston and Sophie, whose murderous secrets threaten to poison the whole town. As their daughter-in-law plots a desperate escape with her young son, one thing becomes chillingly clear: there's no place like Kosher Harbor... and no escape from it.