A substitute mail-order bride? Bear Baldwin is crushed when he receives a wire notifying him that the woman with whom he has corresponded for almost a year has passed him off to her friend. Do the two women think he's like an old shirt to be handed down? His mother urges him to give the substitute fiancee a chance, but his pride is stung and he hasn't decided. Tabitha Masterson is certain whatever awaits her in Radford Springs, Texas will be better than what her brother and that awful William have in mind in Boston. After her father's death, her brother has become a tyrant. She escapes to start her new life in Texas, but trouble can't be far behind. She believes if she's married when trouble arrives, she'll be safe. But her fiance is reluctant to accept her as a substitute for the mail-order bride he'd courted.