Jodi Nelson's parents force her to a Pray-Away-The-Gay session at their church after someone sends pictures of Jodi kissing another girl to her father. Jodi is attacked in one of the rooms in the lower level of the church after the lead minister takes her downstairs to let her collect herself and leaves her alone. After the attack and the humiliation, Jodi runs away and moves in with her best friend, Robert and his mother, who help Jodi get her life together after she realizes she's pregnant.Three years later, Jodi is happily living her life with her young son, Bryan when a strange woman starts stalking her, and her parents show up and demand to be a part of Bryan's life. When Jodi refuses, her parents take her to court and try to get custody of Bryan. Jodi goes to the ACLU for help. Her case is given to the former family judge, Jean Carlisle, who gladly takes the case pro bono. With Jean's help, Jodi is going to stand her ground against the people who would try to take Bryan from her. She will prove that a single lesbian can be a perfect mother. And in the custody hearings proceed, the truth about the attack on Jodi and who was behind it is revealed.