Mandy Elliott has always wanted a family and prays God will give her one. She spends her days teaching and chasing children who eventually go home with someone else at the end of the day. But she dreams of the little girl she lost and the family they could have been. To ease her loneliness, Mandy fills her calendar until there isn't a spare moment to remember. Dr. Garrett Pike is ambitious and entirely focused on his career, despite the frequent admonitions from his happily settled brother about making time for a family. When tragedy strikes and Garrett becomes a father overnight to his four-year-old niece, he is way out of his depth. He turns to the only person he can think of - the intriguing daycare owner he met exactly one time and then ghosted without calling for the date he promised. Mandy thinks God has given her everything she wants - a ready-made family with a man who makes her stomach do backflips. Garrett, on the other hand, never wanted any of it. Suddenly, he has the perfect girlfriend and an adorable daughter on top of a job he can barely manage. Work. Family. Faith. Kissing. Can one person really have it all? Can two?