Amanda and Charlie Spears lived in Kars, Ontario, Canada. For years, they tried to have children to no avail. One day, a miracle happened. There was an accident, the death of a mother, and an unknown child left behind. For 17 years, they raised Mary Spears as their own until a chance reading of a personal ad in the newspaper. A young man was looking for his long lost sister. Amanda and Charlie had a dilemma. Should they respond to the ad and risk losing their daughter? Was it fair to Mary? Was it fair to the young man? Their decision starts them down a path of conflicting emotion, pain and regret.