Gabriella McPherson's life is turned upside down when the father of her young son reappears back in her life. Much to her surprise, Billy Carter hasn't changed at all. He is still the same selfish boy that broke her heart over five years ago. Not only does she not buy his lies, she has something else on her mind these days. Jake Riley. The young man that made her feel love again and break down those walls that she put up after Billy left her destitute.
When Billy decides he is not budging until she has forgiven him, Gabriella decides enough is enough and sends him away. Just when she believes to be better off without Billy in her life, a secret is revealed of Billy's true reason for returning to his small hometown. Suddenly, everything she ever thought about Billy is untrue and she must now confront her past and learn to forgive.