For Leo, winter break always meant tearing it up at Chaplin Point's annual Christmas scavenger hunt. Not this year. Instead, he's made plans with three of the geekiest kids in school. Leo can't imagine a more cringe-worthy night than one involving sweatpants, Netflix, and aliens. Even if his dad finds out and makes good on the military school threat, Leo's hell-bent on making it to The Point, geeks in tow. Going to the party of the year is exactly what Faith needs to ignore her suspicions her boyfriend is lying about his Christmas plans. She wants to win the scavenger hunt and take home the cash prize. Anything to take her mind off confronting him and what comes next. Concerns about the party plague Natalie. Among them: never being able to escape the nickname "Shorty McTits" and her growing attraction to Leo. When he dares her to team up with him for the scavenger hunt, she ignores the butterflies in her stomach and meets his challenge. But when Leo and Natalie get picked up by the cops, plans change. As the foursome race through a night fueled by beer, mimes, and bullies, they all must choose between who they are and who they want to be.