Caught in a romantic triangle with her brother's best friend and a charming pastor, former call girl Carly Lawrence struggles to start a new life. To escape her past, she must learn to forgive herself and Alan Rutledge, her sometimes-boyfriend and owner of Rutledge Escort Services. Abandoned as a child, Joe Callahan, Carly's former neighbor and now a Buffalo police officer, must forgive his mother before he can fully forgive Carly her past and earn her trust. When Carly meets Ryan Edgar, a young minister pastoring his first church, she finds his attraction to her amusing. Surely, he must realize she could never make a suitable pastor's wife. Does her attraction to these two men mean she hasn't changed at all?