Sara Smith hates Sam Reece and Sam Reece hates Sara Smith. There's no one in their group of friends and family that would deny that truth, but when Sam's life is in danger because of a curse cast 136 years ago on Garrison's founding families by a powerful witch intent on avenging the death of her daughter, Sara may be his only hope. As Sara delves deeper into the world of tarot cards, witchcraft, and the curse in an attempt to repair her relationship with her best friend Beige, she's shocked to uncover secrets in her own family history that connect the father she's always trusted to Sam's impending death. Will she be able to let go of her prejudices against Sam and his family in time to play her part in defeating the curse, or will she allow her fear of magic to paralyze her, sealing the fate of Beige's true love and the town of Garrison? Will Sam sacrifice the anger that fills his heart when it comes to Sara and choose trust and love over hate, or will his death be the result of his inability to forgive? Sacrificing Sara reunites the characters from Saving Beige and Revealing Marisa as they embark on the quest to put and end to the Denoncourt curse once and for all.