Thirteen years ago, five confirmed bachelors were accused of a hit-and-run accident that left Poppy Careen dead on a quiet residential street. Now Poppy's mother asks Odelia to finally get justice for her family. But when Odelia pays a visit to one of the five men, she finds he's been murdered. The most likely suspects are the Careens, especially Poppy's dad, who never fully recovered from the death of his little girl. But soon other suspects pop out of the woodwork, and when more bodies are discovered, it becomes clear that there's a lot more to this case than meets the eye.