It's nothing personal. But Gemma doesn't want to carry on with Jack after a one-night stand. She's busy working seventy-hour weeks at a law firm, and after her last relationship totally blew up in her face, she's not exactly eager to give dating another try. But for reasons she can't understand, out of the millions of people in New York City, she keeps bumping into Jack. He's a hopeless romantic who thinks it's the universe or fate bringing them together, but she's adamant that their crossing paths is just a fluke. He's determined to prove that it's so much more than that.