Judas Taylor has come back to his hometown of Sweet Water, Michigan as their new sheriff. However, there are some things he did not foresee, such as Delaney McDermott, his first love, showing up again after he'd left her at the altar seventeen years ago.Delaney (Laney) McDermott, returns to the little town of Sweet Water where she lost not only her virginity but also her heart to Judas Taylor. Now, after the death of her husband, she knows she needs to find Judas and tell him the truth about her troublesome, pregnant teenage daughter. But never did she suspect that before she could tell him, Judas would be arresting his own daughter.Will bygones be forgotten between Laney and Judas, or will two people who are ashamed of things they've done in the past be brought back together by an uncommon circumstance in Judging Judas?