Five single women living on an island off the coast of Maine. The men are few and far between, but the minute a good looking man comes in on the ferry, they all know about it. When Mallory sees Michael when he gets off the ferry, the first thing she does is text her friends: I Saw Him First. Michael is a writer who has come for peace and quiet to finish writing his novel. He didn't expect to fall in love. As Mallory and Michael explore their new relationship, can they get past the differences in what they want and their two very different lifestyles? Can love really conquer all?