Leah Johnson, Betsy Taylor West, and twins Rachel and Sarah Johnson were not born when Lexie Logan disappeared from the lives of their parents more than twenty-five years earlier, yet the Bells, Johnsons, and Wests still whisper about this mysterious woman when they don't think others are listening.
Even Matthew Bell and the former slave, Peter, who knew Lexie, refuse to answer questions about her. The girls' determination to find answers and solve the riddle of Lexie Logan lead them to an answer that is both shocking and unbelievable.