It's another murder to solve for the Amish Secret Widows' Society. An elderly Amish man, rumoured to be in the possession of paintings worth millions of dollars, is found poisoned. Can the widows find out who killed him before there is another murder? Emma Kurtzler is in love with Wil Jacobson but struggles with it being too soon to marry after the death of her husband. Meanwhile, Silvie Keim is swept off her feet by Bailey Abler, a mysterious stranger who is staying within the community and proclaims he wants to be Amish. What connection does Bailey have to the murdered man that will shock the community? What will Silvie do when she discovers Bailey's true identity?