Nick Winters and Maddie Graves are officially a couple - and more importantly, they're officially happy. They're finally on the road to forever. When a body washes up on the Lake Michigan shoreline, though, the couple finds themselves embroiled in another mystery - and the stakes are high. Local teenager Hayley Walker was missing two weeks before her body was discovered, although her autopsy indicates she's only been dead for twenty-four hours. Because of the age of the victim - and the way her body was discarded - the death rocks the community. Between a suspicious boyfriend, legends of a local "pervert" running around the docks and a mysterious older fisherman, the couple have their pick of suspects. That's on top of the teen's parents, who are hiding a few secrets of their own. Nick and Maddie have love on their side, even if they're still struggling with Marla's machinations and Cassidy's anger at every turn. When the pieces finally fit together, it might be too late for Maddie. Can Nick get to her in time, and can this couple give peace to a restless soul before it's too late?