What do you do when you start to question the decision you made when you were 18? A decision that shaped the rest of your days? Gifford lives in Northern Minnesota with an aspiring politician for a wife, several sled dogs, and a poodle. He is a reparative therapist (praying the gay away) and active in his church. When he starts counseling Rusty, he begins to wonder what his life would be like if he had chosen a different path.