Returning home after three years in a seminary, Kevin Davis holds tight to the reason why he refuses to go back. No one can pry the truth from him, not his parents, his brother, or his twin sister. But when an old love stumbles back into his life, he gradually begins to share, and struggles with the direction he wants his life to go, a pen pal who wants to be much more than friends, and an unfortunate streak with fire. Finding Father Rabbit follows the entire Davis family over two years, from Kevin's return home, to the explosion of his secret revealed.