Elora used to be a fashion-forward girl until one day of freshman year when everything changed. She fell for John. John is the captain of the baseball team and popular. Not only does Elora have her eyes set on him, but so does Julie. Julie is the mean girl of the school. She wants John and will do whatever it takes to get him; even if that means tearing Elora down in the process. Now, at seventeen years old, Elora is still certain she won't ever have a chance with him, but that's not her only problem. She's different than she once was. All the years of being on Julie's bad side has taken a toll on her. Tallie, her best friend, refuses to let Elora be anyone other than who she really is. She isn't going to give up until she has the old Elora back, and hopes to push her into John's arms along the way.