Worried by an unexpected increase in her caseload, social worker Ellie Mittelstadt is looking for anything to make her smile. When she stops in a fortune teller's tent at the Haralson Fall Festival, however, she never expects the psychic to predict she'll fall in love-and with a man named "Chris Evans." What are the odds? Worse, she quickly discovers five Chris Evanses in Haralson, which means Ellie can only determine her perfect match via bold-and occasionally hysterical-trial and error. Still, she can't help wonder...what if? Dr. John Christopher Evans is new to Haralson, and it's been a challenging first week. He has a hospital administrator who can't read his handwriting and business cards and ID badge that read Dr. John Enars, and his first patient is a young boy with an illness that defies diagnosis. The only person keeping the child company is his social worker, Ellie-who instantly charms John with her gentle smile and generous heart. If he had any game, he'd ask her out...but after mourning his late wife for the past couple of years then getting so caught up in his work, he doesn't even know where to begin. Ellie's campaign for true love is going nowhere fast, but at least she's distracted with her newest charge-and his strong, caring physician "Dr. John", who'd be perfect except he's not Chris Evans...and he's still wearing a wedding band. How in the world will she ever find romance when she can't stop thinking about Mr. Wrong? Fortunately for Ellie, fate has things well in hand...