When a former classmate throws a high school reunion, it drums up some not so sweet memories for dessert shop proprietor Chase Oliver and her friend Julie Larson. Back in the day, Ron North had a creepy crush on Julie - and his social graces haven't exactly improved with age. But is he creepy enough that someone would kill him for it? When Chase's cat Quincy escapes his harness and leads Chase to Ron's body, the police wonder who else got away. Now, with Julie suspected, Chase must prove her innocence before the real killer plans another fatal reunion.