The unique perspective of this book--Dr. Macdonald is VietNam War combat veteran, Episcopal priest, and scholar--makes it at once insightful and provocative. Apart from the wide reading and impressive learning of the author, the book seeks to avoid glib assertions and simplistic answers to one of America's wars that still defies a superficial summary. Dr. Macdonald can acknowledge the folly of some of America's policymakers and politicians without impugning the staggering heroism and sacrifices of so many American troops who served and fought in VietNam. He knows. He was there. This book adds a needed, and valuable, perspective.