Annie Benson, widowed and seven months pregnant with twins, is convinced God doesn't waste time on unimportant people like her. She's working as a waitress in a little California town when she receives word she's inherited a small ranch in Wyoming. Excited and relieved, Annie wants to spend Christmas in her new home. As she exits the bus, a very handsome man offers her a hand. He is the local doctor and her new neighbor, Gabriel St. Nick. While stuck in a snowstorm and in labor, can Gabe convince Annie that God loves her and so does he?