Three years have passed since Creatureton Elementary, and Sally Salamander Squibly, non-monster monster, is a 16 y/o student at Rydell High with her best friend Logan. Yet, the world of the magus has been thrown into a state of turmoil. Witches and Warlocks everywhere have come to both praise and curse the imprisoned Warlock, Mad Mulligan, for having successfully created a hybrid-the first ever fusing of a Vampire and a Werewolf. Some wish to create hybrids of their own, while others wish to prevent the creation of such a creature. Miss Glinda has devised a plan for stopping the dissident magic-users from achieving their goal, but to do so Sally would have to become the Hybrid again. Meanwhile, Sally struggles with being a teenager. A young man has caught her attention and ensnared her heart. Phelan is charming and handsome, but is he simply too good to be true? And will Sally survive the betrayal of those closest to her, or succumb to the despair that threatens to destroy her dreams of a happy life?