"What's something you want to do that you've never done?" The question shouldn't have led to anything, and yet it changed the trajectory of my entire life. After my brother's wedding, while drowning my sorrows and loneliness in booze, I accepted an offer for one reckless night with a man nineteen years my senior. No promises. No expectations. We might see each other again-or never cross paths. So, why not? A year later, I'm dating someone completely new. Noah Dawson. A good man. The kind who treats me like I'm precious. Like I'm something worth keeping. It should have been simple. Easy. Until he takes me to his stepdad's birthday party... and I come face to face with the man who changed my life. Now fate has a twisted sense of humor. Because I could walk away. I should walk away. But if I don't, I won't just be choosing one of them. I'll be choosing both. Sean Calloway told me that very first night that he and his stepson share women. They're a package deal. And now, they want to share me.