Maya Vanderstroop has abandoned her dream of becoming a professional musician and spends her days cleaning teeth for an unscrupulous dentist. Her boyfriend Joey is a workout fanatic and a materialistic mama's boy who can't seem to move their relationship forward. Maya's self-doubt and ambivalent feelings about Joey cause her to believe her life is at a standstill. Eventually Maya realizes she is giving too much and taking too little and ends the affair. Intent on renewing her musical passion, she then makes a startling purchase-a piano-that attracts the attention of Rosa, her psychic landlady who makes an astonishing prediction about Maya's romantic future. Maya is delighted, but is soon faced with a myriad of difficult choices. While deciding whether to continue dating the sexy and dangerous Marcus or go out with Justin, a geeky dentist with a chip on his shoulder, Maya must also determine if she can trust a shifty talent agent full of promises about her future music career. Before she can finally move forward, Maya needs to overcome the one last hurdle that is preventing a union with her perfect mate-or is he destined to become the fish that got away?