Atheism's rebellion against spirituality is doomed to eventual irrelevance because scientific research has verified metaphysical reality. The human soul with an afterlife, as part of this reality, makes earthly death a gateway to an eternal existence rather than an end of human existence. This creates atheism's dilemma, of accepting or rejecting this reality, by dismantling atheistic dogmatic ideology. Atheistic ideology denies the reality of the human soul, an afterlife, and God s existence. But scientifically researched evidence of reincarnation proves that there is a soul that can separate from the body at earthly death, retaining its mind, memory, and free will of the previous life, and enter another body during its pregnancy. Over two thousand researched cases have verified reincarnation, in which physical evidence combined with verified claims of the previous lives connect the two lives. Therefore, reincarnation refutes the atheistic ideology, with spiritual reality greatly increasing the probability of God s existence. With a baseless ideology, what will atheism do to continue as a viable belief? This is Atheism s Dilemma "