When Selena is first given the Angel Handbook, she has every intention of sticking to the rules. Then the Council of Archangels sends her on a special assignment to help a high school cheerleader, and she realizes that the rules are actually getting in the way. Especially since Ashley's snobby group of friends, tyrannical math teacher and crazy stepmother seem to be working against her. Thankfully Selena has a notorious rule-breaker for a best friend, and with Hermes' advice, she comes up with a sure-fire way to help Ashley change her life. She is going to get her to fall in love. But Selena playing Cupid has an unexpected consequence. She ends up falling in love herself. Having a boyfriend is definitely going against the rules, and so Selena must decide... Does she follow the Angel Handbook or does she follow her heart?