What would you do if you just found out you have a four-year-old daughter? Jude is happily married, has a successful career, and his wife is expecting their first child. Then the paternity test comes back positive. It can't be. Jude hires his friend Sam, an attorney, but he can do little more than lend an ear to a friend. Jude decides to meet his daughter -- to prove to himself that the test was wrong. But she looks too much like him. When Madelyn's grandparents are no longer able to care for her and she's put into a foster home, Jude's paternal instincts dictate his moves. He brings Madelyn home to live with him. Then Noelle, Jude's wife, sees the little girl. . .and his hope for a happy family is shattered.