Oh Captain, My Captain presents Brody Ross of the Indiana Mustangs. Brody Ross was one of the youngest captains in the hockey league. His one and only goal is lift the Cup over his head. That is until he moved next door to Selene Porter. When he approaches her with a proposal, their friendship takes a turn. However, it comes at a price when an ex-flame appears in the picture. Selene Porter has two loves: her dog, Bonkers, and hockey. She's been a lifelong fan of the Indiana Mustangs and their Captain. She refuses to let anything take away what means so much to her and Brody, his career, and his old fling has her wondering if love is worth the risk. With the unwanted presence, can Brody and Selene stick together or will Selene back out of the proposal?